OPEN ISSUE #5: Abiding in the Doctrine of Christ

By Bruce Reeves

Synopsis: In every generation, some disciples drift into apostasy. Personalities may change, but the peril persists: A desire to be like the surrounding nations (or human denominations) inevitably leads to a loss of distinctiveness, and ultimately, spiritual identity.


Introduction

Jesus Christ is the centerpiece of the Bible. We see His glory as Creator, Messiah, Savior, Lord, King, High Priest, and Judge. The glorious Son of God is found both in prophecy and promise. We see Him in His virgin birth, sinless life, masterful teaching, selfless ministry, sacrificial death, powerful resurrection, glorious ascension, and divine reign for the salvation of humanity. Not only is this true in His fulfillment of the Old Testament prophecies and promises, but it is also true of the New Testament’s portrayal of His life and sacrifice. Whether one studies the nature of grace, faith, baptism, the Lord’s supper, moral sanctification, discipleship, the church and her organization, work, worship, or (for that matter) the second coming—Jesus Christ is at the heart of God’s message! If we miss this truth, we miss the power of the gospel and the beauty of the doctrine of Christ.

Yet, there are those who, under the guise of preaching more about the cross and grace, are undermining the fullness of the gospel. An attempt among some of our brethren has been under way to deemphasize the doctrine of Christ. This is happening through the redefining of phrases and terms, such as “sound doctrine,” “fellowship,” “grace,” “authority,” and “pattern.” It has become rather trendy to slander those who believe in “pattern theology” as cold-hearted and formalistic in their faith. Misrepresentations and mischaracterizations are par for the course in such controversies. Labels such as “Pharisees,” “legalists,” “truth-protectors,” and “traditionalists” have been weaponized to dismiss a serious consideration of doctrinal questions. Misunderstandings of those terms, the unrighteous judgments of others, and diversions from the actual issues evade what is really at stake: our identity, mission, relationship with God, purpose, and salvation.

What Is the Background of the Gospel-Doctrine Distinction?

The gospel-doctrine distinction has been quite popular in the religious world at large, but it is very unbiblical. Proponents of the grace-unity movement will inevitably attempt to redefine either the “gospel of Christ” or the “doctrine of Christ” to justify a compromising spirit toward religious error. The motto “Let’s preach the man and not the plan” is wholly unscriptural. Christ cannot be separated from His word, commandments, or teaching (Matt. 7:24-27; John 12:47-48; 14:15). Some have said that the problem is that we have been “majoring in minors.” Of course, statements like this one must be explained. There are issues that do not impact our salvation that are matters about which God is indifferent (Rom. 14:1-15:3). Yet if one means that the way we worship, the work and mission of the local congregation, marriage, divorce, and remarriage, or moral issues should not be discussed openly, then such a concept should be rejected out of hand (1 Tim. 3:15; 4:1-6; 2 Tim. 4:1-5).

There have been multiple waves of the Grace-Unity Movement among churches of Christ throughout the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s. It has now entered the thinking of some brethren again. The position has been clearly stated by its advocates in the past. Carl Ketcherside wrote, “Not one apostolic letter is part of the gospel of Christ. . . the letter to the Galatians was not a part of the gospel. . .” What an amazing statement considering the truth that Paul is offering a doctrinal defense of the gospel of grace in this splendid epistle. How could anyone say the book of Galatians is not part of the gospel of Christ? Ketcherside went on to say,

No honest opinion held by one who is in Christ Jesus and who respects His lordship is “another gospel.” Since it is the gospel which forms the basis of the fellowship with the Father, the Son and with one another in Christ, such an opinion can never be made a test of union or communion in Christ. A man may hold a view as to the perseverance of the saints, the manner of the resurrection, or the second coming of our Lord, and he may prove to be as wrong as one could be, but he cannot be debarred from citizenry in the kingdom of heaven by the other subjects. . . No man “preaches another gospel” simply by being mistaken about some aspects of the will of God, otherwise one would need to know perfectly the divine will or be a perverter of the gospel. . . Regardless of motive, [those who oppose gospel/doctrine distinction, B.R.] reveal that they are ignorant of what constitutes both gospel and apostasy (Carl Ketcherside, “Another Gospel,” Twisted Scriptures, Mission Messenger, 4-9).

Again, this error avows that the nature of our assurance in Christ, the coming resurrection, and even teaching about the Lord’s return, are not considered part of the gospel. Leroy Garrett demonstrated why he was asserting this teaching:

The implications of all this to unity and fellowship are weighty. It means that the gospel itself, not our doctrinal interpretations, is the basis of our being one in Christ and in fellowship with each other. That is, when one believes in Jesus and obeys Him in baptism, he is our brother and in the fellowship. . . This is oneness and this is unity. That fellowship is strengthened and made joyful by doctrine, but it is the gospel and not doctrine that determines the fellowship”(Leroy Garrett).

The implications of all this to unity and fellowship are weighty indeed. Without the teaching coming from and about Jesus Christ, we have no fellowship (2 John 9-11). Arnold Hardin likewise wrote, “The gospel is not defined as everything in the New Testament. . . not all truth is gospel; though all truth is for our instruction.”

Charles L. Loos said, “Doctrines do not save us; we are saved by Christ. Doctrines do not cleanse us from our sins; it is the efficacious blood of Christ. . . We are not baptized into [doctrines], but into Christ. We do not hope in them, trust in them, glory in them, but in Christ Jesus our Lord” (Leonard Allen quoting Charles L. Loos, teacher with Campbell at Bethany College, 89). Yet, how would we know about salvation in Jesus, the atonement, faith in Christ, or baptism were it not for the doctrine of Christ revealed in Scripture? These types of arguments meet themselves coming back and are self-contradictory. The “core-gospel” approach argues that the birth, life, death, burial, resurrection, ascension, coronation, and glorification of Christ constitutes the gospel? Are “faith,” “repentance,” “confession,” and “baptism” not a part of the gospel (Eph. 4:4-7)? If so, which one is and which one is not? Various people offer different determinations. Is the gospel limited to these facts alone? We only determine the gospel of Christ through the teaching revealed in the Bible.

Do the Scriptures Distinguish between the Gospel and Doctrine of Christ?

The gospel-doctrine distinction is not merely a matter of wrongly defining biblical words. It is also a mechanism for departure and widespread change of vital aspects of the fellowship of God’s people. In the New Testament, the term “gospel” denotes the good news of the kingdom of God and the term “doctrine” simply refers to “teaching” or “instruction.” The gospel includes the facts of Jesus (1 Cor. 15:1-4) and the interpretation of these facts expressed as teaching or doctrine (Matt. 4:23; Acts 20:24; 28:31; Rom. 1:16; 10:16; 1 Thess. 2:2). The gospel is expressed in facts to be believed, commands to be obeyed, and promises to be enjoyed (Mark 16:15-16; Rom. 6:3-4; Col. 2:11-13). The grace of God offers instruction that leads to godliness and salvation (Titus 2:11-15).

There are several synonyms for the message of the gospel in Acts 13:7-12. Note that the phrases “the word of God” (13:7), “the faith” (13:8), “all righteousness” (13:10), “straight ways of the Lord” (13:10), and “the doctrine of the Lord” (13:12) all refer to the same message. Paul’s farewell to the elders at Ephesus encouraged them to “be on guard for yourselves and for all the flock, among which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers, to shepherd the church of God which He purchased with His own blood. I know that after my departure, savage wolves will come in among you, not sparing the flock, and from among your own selves’ men will arise, speaking perverse things to draw away disciples after them” (Acts 20:28-30). He also declared that he was innocent of the blood of all men because he did not “shrink from declaring to you the whole purpose of God” (Acts 20:27). Did this not include the qualities and work of elders (Acts 20:17, 28), “the gospel of the grace of God” (Acts 20:24), and error of false teachers (Acts 20:28; Titus 1:9-11)?

Paul wrote that he was looking forward to preaching the gospel to the beloved saints at Rome (Rom. 1:15-16). How could this be possible if the gospel only included the death, burial, and resurrection of Jesus Christ? He was speaking to the “beloved of God, called to be saints.” Therefore, he was not going to preach the gospel only to the unsaved, but also to the saved. The terms “gospel,” “doctrine,” “truth,” and “message” refer to the same body of information. Sometimes the terms are even combined—as in the phrase, “the gospel of truth” (Gal. 2:5; 5:7). Each term simply emphasizes different features of God’s message. It should also be noted that the terms “gospel” and “doctrine” are used interchangeably.

For example, consider 1 Timothy 1:8–11, where the inspired apostle identifies violations of divine law as behavior that is “contrary to sound doctrine,” (that was) “in accordance with the gospel” with which he had been entrusted:

Now we know that the law is good, if one uses it lawfully, understanding this, that the law is not laid down for the just but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who strike their fathers and mothers, for murderers, the sexually immoral, men who practice homosexuality, enslavers, liars, perjurers, and whatever else is contrary to sound doctrine, in accordance with the gospel of the glory of the blessed God with which I have been entrusted (1 Tim. 1:8-11, ESV).

Those who are constantly castigating faithful brethren for traditionalism may want to consider the difference in human traditions being bound on others (Matt. 15:9), versus the divine traditions of the apostles, which believers are to obey (2 Thess. 2:15; 3:6, 14). We are to preach the word with doctrinal instruction and longsuffering (2 Tim. 4:2). The apostles’ teaching was necessary for the salvation and fellowship of the Lord’s people (Matt. 28:20; Acts 2:42; 1 Cor. 11:1-2, 17-18; Col. 1:5).

Should fellowship exclude doctrine? Paul says that the faithful are to identify and turn away from those who are teaching those things contrary to the doctrine which we have learned from God’s word (Rom. 16:17). Likewise, teachers are charged to teach no other doctrine, and believers are admonished to “abide in the doctrine of Christ” (1 Tim. 1:3, 10; 4:1, 6, 13, 16; 6:1, 3; 2 Tim. 3:10, 16; 4:3; Titus 1:9; 2:1, 7, 10; 2 John 9-11). No one is claiming sinless perfectionism, but we are called to obedience from the heart (Rom. 6:17). We are transformed and renewed by God’s grace as we surrender to His love (Rom. 12:1-2; Eph. 4:22-24). Christ’s blood cleanses us from all unrighteousness as we walk in His light and confess our sins (1 John 1:7-2:2). Why do these kinds of issues arise among brethren? John wrote, “They went out from us, but they were not really of us; for if they had been of us, they would have remained with us; but they went out, so that it would be shown that they all are not of us” (1 John 2:19). He is not speaking of their geographical location, but of their spiritual condition and doctrinal soundness. This movement of divisive brethren against the truth had left the original ground of their spiritual unity, apostolic teaching, and the faith once delivered (Acts 2:42; 1 Cor. 1:10; Jude 3-4). In effect, John is saying, “We did not change: they did. We did not go anywhere: they did. We believe what we have believed all along. They are the ones who abandoned the truth, and broke fellowship with those who conform to its demands.”

How Is This Doctrine Presented Today?

Those who promote these types of doctrines usually follow the same pattern. They attempt to build dissatisfaction so that their agendas will be received. Scare tactics are used in statements such as, “If you don’t believe what I’m saying, then all our young Christians will leave in droves.” There is significant self-promotion and disrespect toward previous generations of faithful brethren. Obedience to Christ will be described as impossible and there will be incessant disruption, dissatisfaction, and deception of the naïve and unsuspecting.

While many have seen that the hard and fast distinction between the gospel and doctrine is a fallacious perspective, they may adopt a similar approach by diluting the phrase “sound doctrine.” We frequently will see a deliberate effort to deemphasize and dismiss the New Testament pattern found in the epistles as well as the basic rules of communication (command, approved example, and necessary conclusions). Ironically, those who profess to be “Jesus-centered” are disavowing the pattern Jesus left us for interpreting God’s will (Matt. 19:4-6).

Another tactic is to use examples of human opinion to mask false views about essential aspects of the faith. The redefining of biblical terms unbiblically is something about which we must always be sensitive in our understanding of the truth. For instance, the notion that the phrase “sound doctrine” has no application to the “organization of the church, the work of the local church, how we use funds. . . how we conduct worship” is contrary to the letters Paul wrote to Timothy and Titus, where the phrase is found (1 Tim. 1:8-11; 6:3-4, 12, 20; 2 Tim. 1:13; 4:1-5; Titus 1:9-13). Soundness is both personal and congregational (1 Tim. 3:15). It includes instructions regarding the organization, mission, work, benevolence, and worship of the local church (1 Cor. 5:1-13; 2 Thess. 3:6; 1 Tim. 2:9-15; 3:1-13; 5:8-16, 19-20; Rev. 2-3).

The current trend to redefine and limit the application of “sound doctrine” is an attempt to broaden congregational fellowship beyond the biblical framework. The “either/or” fallacy must be recognized. It argues: “Either we emphasize Jesus or the biblical pattern,” “either we emphasize grace or obedience,” “either we emphasize love and faith or the authority of the Scriptures.” Brethren, we can and must emphasize God’s grace and the surrender of obedience, Christ’s love and His preeminent authority as King of kings, and we must proclaim the Son of God as Savior, Lord, and Judge!

The following quotation indicates a serious problem in the thinking of some of our brethren and jeopardizes new and young Christians to spiritual danger:

You remember lessons where the word “authority” was mentioned many, many, many times. And it was dissected, and things were drilled down. And you remember lessons about gopher wood, and red heifers, and strange fire. And you remember about all those examples that we see that talk about how God views things in relation to what He said, in relation to what He hasn’t said and how He interacts with His people based on those things. And if you have been paying attention very long at all, you know that I have not done lessons like that. I have not done lessons where I used Gopher Wood as an example of God’s authority and what He has spoken. You’ve never heard me do a lesson on specific or generic authority. We’ve not had any lessons on instrumental music or how the church should spend its money. And I admit to that, that those lessons have not been taught (Elijah Aaron, “It’s a Lot Deeper Than That,” March 21, 2023, Northside church of Christ, Conway, Arkansas).

The path of doctrinal change in churches can be gradual at first, but rapid as things continue to digress. There are four stages of departure:

What happens when we stop preaching on the context of Scripture and the application of biblical principles to questions that arise? Hearers come to believe that those topics are unimportant and are merely matters of human tradition. Disciples are susceptible to being misled, and we show a lack of love for our brethren. Shepherds have a responsibility to continue to build up mature Christians, as well as young believers and new converts. As parents, we have a responsibility to lead our children in the way of the Lord (Eph. 6:4).

Where Is This Going?

If this approach is successful, it will not be possible to defend “sound doctrine,” because the concept will be so very subjective that only the deity of Christ and immorality will matter anymore. It is my conviction that faithful brethren will see these notions for the dangerous, but bankrupt ideas that they are and fervently embrace the truth of the gospel. We must listen well. Those who use unscriptural terminology and arguments are playing with fire that will harm the “unstable” and “immature” (2 Pet. 2:14; Eph. 4:14). Let us embrace the love, grace, and mercy of God while also embracing the power of the gospel to change lives, guide disciples, and mold every aspect of our service to our King and God.

Bibliography

Aaron, Elijah. “It’s a Lot Deeper Than That.” Northside church of Christ. Conway, AR. March 21, 2023. Available online at https://www.northsidecofc.com/sermons/its-a-lot-deeper-than-that/

Garrett, Leroy. “The Word Abused. . . ‘If We Or An Angel Preach Any Other Gospel.’” Restoration Review. (Volume 17, Number 3, pp. 42-46 [March, 1975]) via Tom M. Roberts, “The Gospel/Doctrine Distinction: Bred in Infidelity; Nurtured by Cynicism; Spread by Discontent.” Guardian of Truth. (XXXVIII: 13, p. 16-18 [July 7, 1994]). Available online at https://digitalcommons.acu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1131&context=restorationreview.

Ketcherside, Carl. “Another Gospel” Twisted Scriptures. Mission Messenger. 1965, pp. 4, 7-9, via Mike Willis, “The Word Abused: Galatians 1:8-9.” Truth Magazine, (XIX: 40, pp. 632-636 [August 21, 1975]).

Ketcherside, W. Carl. “The Twisted Scriptures: Another Gospel.” Mission Messenger. [Originally published in St. Louis, MO, 1965] Reprinted by DeFuniak Springs, FL: A Signal Hill Book, 1992. Available online at https://webfiles.acu.edu/departments/Library/HR/restmov_nov11/www.mun.ca/rels/restmov/texts/wcketcherside/tts/chap3.html


Author Image
Article Image
Ad Image