By Bruce Reeves
Synopsis: Those who attempt to divorce daily discipleship from in-depth biblical teaching will inevitably pursue a path of superficiality that dilutes and compromises what it means to be a true follower of Jesus.
It has been a blessing to explore the nature of God, sacrifice of Christ, and fullness of our salvation in this column as we have contrasted biblical teaching with Calvinistic teachings. Sadly, there are those both in the pew and pulpit who have come to believe that reviewing false doctrines like Calvinism is a waste of time and has no bearing on our daily discipleship. This absence of comprehensive teaching creates a context that exposes the vulnerable to deception. Changing terminology and offering empty denials may mislead the naïve, but if the concepts are expressing error, it is still error. Paul writes, “Now I urge you, brethren, keep your eye on those who cause dissensions and hindrances contrary to the teaching which you learned, and turn away from them. For such men are slaves, not of our Lord Jesus Christ but of their own appetites; and by their smooth and flattering speech they deceive the hearts of the unsuspecting” (Rom. 16:17-18). Admiring the majestic beauty of God’s powerful reign, matchless love, generous grace, and amazing salvation shapes everything about our lives as children of God (Eph. 5:1-2). Therefore, any teaching that undermines, distorts, or attacks the moral and ethical goodness of our Father must be repudiated.
In this final article of our theme, “The Love of God,” let us consider Calvinism’s impact on our everyday life. While proponents of Reformed Theology attempt to discount the practical consequences of their doctrine; the inconsistencies of Calvinism remain and should be considered. The consequences of unbiblical teachings about God, sin, humanity, and salvation can be riveting and critical to our walk with our Savior.
The following questions are worthy of consideration:
How should we understand God’s love for the unconverted?
Can we tell a person, with certainty, that Jesus died for them?
What should we say to someone who has been sexually abused?
How should we interpret this abuse theologically?
Did God predetermine and cause the perpetrator to abuse others?
Is God the first cause of all evil?
Why evangelize the lost?
Does God redemptively love all of humanity?
Are we ultimately responsible for our behavior?
Does prayer have the potential to influence the mind of God?
These are questions that those who proclaim the true and living God to a sinful world must contemplate. Skeptics prefer to attack the Calvinistic interpretation of God, rather than the biblical presentation of His nature and works. Understanding the scope of God’s love and the power of the gospel is crucial to our work as the Lord’s people. Let us discuss two major areas of our discipleship that are influenced by Calvinism, i.e., evangelism and our interpretation of suffering in a wicked world.
Reformed Theology cannot make coherent sense of its claim that God genuinely offers salvation to those He has not unconditionally chosen. Calvinism teaches that all people are born totally depraved and disabled and thus lack the freedom to choose faith in Christ. The reason for this belief is the doctrine’s contention that only those who have been unconditionally elected are given the irresistible and direct operation of the Holy Spirit, which provides the gift of faith for salvation. We are told that the outward call of the gospel is expressed to all, but only the unconditionally elected will receive the irresistible inward call of grace. The logical conclusion is that God invites humanity to come to salvation, knowing from eternity that the vast majority cannot come because of His determinative will. He calls most of humanity to come to Him having ordained that they cannot come and then condemns them for not doing what they were unable to do! Does this fit with the loving and compassionate God who is revealed in Scripture? Certainly not.
Although many Calvinists tell people they can know God loves them, they do so despite their doctrine, not because of it. Reducing God’s love to physical blessings alone is disingenuous considering our desperate need for forgiveness, yet this is what Calvinists must do in speaking of the Lord’s universal love for humanity. Writers such as John Piper and John MacArthur will argue that we have been commanded to preach the gospel and that it is during such preaching that the Spirit operates on the elect. Yet, the inconsistency is glaring and obvious. According to their teaching, God does not have redemptive love for anyone else and refuses to enable them to do what He commands because He has foreordained their destruction (Acts 17:24-31; 2 Pet. 3:9; 1 John 2:1-2). Thankfully, the true gospel of Christ proclaims the universal and genuine offer of redemption to all those who will come (John 3:16; 1 Tim. 2:1-5; 2 Pet. 3:9; Rev. 22:17). Instead of affirming “Whosoever will. . .”, Calvinism distorts the gospel of grace and debases the Lord’s lovingkindness.
The problem of evil challenges views ranging from theism to agnosticism to atheism. The question of suffering has been a favorite weapon in the skeptic’s arsenal as long as atheists have been doing battle with believers. Ironically, the question backfires on those who deny the existence of God (Reeves, Why Does God Allow Suffering, 64). Critics of theism have often claimed that evil is incompatible with the existence of a loving Creator. According to non-believers, “If there were a God who had the attributes the Bible says He has—omnipotence and perfect goodness—then there would be no evil. For if He is omnipotent, then it seems He has the power to do anything possible, including eradicate all wickedness. If He is perfectly good, then He is opposed to evil and would want to remove it. Yet, because there obviously is evil, there is no such God.” This intellectual challenge requires a rational response that will allow God’s existence to be compatible with the existence of evil (Walls and Dongell, Why I Am Not A Calvinist, 203-215).
We should understand that God having all power does not mean that He always exercises it, especially when it would violate either His nature or greater purposes (Gen. 2:2; Heb. 6:17-19; 2 Pet. 3:1-9; 1 John 1:5), neither does His goodness always conform to our flawed sense of temporary fulfillment (Prov. 14:12; Isa. 55:8-9; 2 Cor. 12:7-10). Interestingly, for the atheist to appeal to the concepts of “goodness,” “justice,” or “morality” is to plagiarize the attributes of God in arguing against Him. The mission of God is to call humanity to a loving relationship with Him, which requires human freedom. As a result, He tolerates many difficult things for the consummation of His divine purpose (Rom. 8:24-38).
Reformed theologians cannot argue that evil exists to preserve human freewill, but that God has predetermined and unchangeably foreordained evil. In fact, Calvinists unashamedly assert that God is the first cause of evil and Satan and men are only secondary causes. With such a doctrine, we ask, “Who is the real devil?” The most powerful moral argument against atheism evaporates with Reformed Theology. Please note: this is not merely a theological, philosophical, or academic discussion. It is also very practical—deeply influencing and shaping how we view the surrounding world, the experience of suffering, and even how we comfort those who are in grief. Those who attempt to divorce daily discipleship from in-depth biblical teaching will head down a path of superficiality that dilutes and compromises what it means to be a true follower of Jesus.
There are other approaches that uphold God’s sovereignty, human freedom, and the realities of sin around us. From a biblical and moral sense, they are much more encouraging. We are not seeking to elevate our thoughts above God’s wisdom, but allow God’s word to transform and instruct our understanding. When our perspectives are refined and revised by Scripture, we will be more and more like Christ (Col. 3:16).
Living by faith does not remove all tensions, struggles, and questions. The apostle Paul reminds us that although we live in a world of decay and struggle, we have a living hope of our future redemption (Rom. 8:23-25). A proper understanding of the biblical message brings hope, but the teaching that God is the first cause of evil has profoundly disturbing implications. Jerry L. Walls and Joseph R. Dongell, in their work “Why I Am Not A Calvinist” cite hypothetical, but real scenarios that bring the problems of Calvinism to light in real time and real life. For example, consider “a teenager who is paralyzed in an automobile accident because the brakes in his car failed,” or “a young girl who is sexually abused by her uncle.” We have all known people who have experienced similar devastation and tragedies. It is one thing to understand these situations as the result of God’s permissive will, although they disgust Him, and which He will judge in the end (2 Thess. 1:6-9). It is something entirely different to argue that God unchangeably foreordained all these kinds of events. Although there are human choices that anger God, they are still within the realm of His sovereignty in that He allows them, but will hold us accountable for our decisions (2 Cor. 5:10-11).
Can we not see that Calvinism completely changes a balanced and reasonable approach to our daily perspectives of life and God? “This teaching is beset with practical inconsistencies that mirror its logical contradictions. This is another powerful reason not to be a Calvinist” (Wall and Dongell, 215).
God’s love is seen in His Son, in His gospel, and in His works. What we believe about His personality and attributes is deeply impactful every day of our lives. It truly informs and matures our faith and shapes our decisions every day. It leads us to God-centered worship, Christ-focused relationships, and blessed fellowship with our Redeemer. Peter writes, “After you have suffered for a little while, the God of all grace, who called you to His eternal glory in Christ, will Himself perfect, confirm, and strengthen and establish you. To Him be dominion forever and ever. Amen” (1 Pet. 5:10-11).
Reeves, Bruce. “Why Does God Allow Suffering?” in Is It Reasonable To Believe In God. Athens: Truth Publications, Inc, 2022 (pages, 49-64).
Walls, Jerry L., and Joseph R. Dongell. Why I Am Not A Calvinist. Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity, 2004.