By Joshua Gurtler
Synopsis: The multiverse is postulated by atheists as the only alternative to an intelligent designer; however, they also admit that the idea of the multiverse is unscientific, thus, there must be a God.
In discussing the universe with an atheistic colleague of mine, we broached the subject of the expanding universe and the boundary that must exist; hence, I asked him what he thought existed outside that boundary. He retorted, “the multiverse, of course.” The idea of the multiverse is that there is an infinite number of alternate universes that are also expanding like variously sized holes in an infinitely large block of Swiss cheese. If you talk to any atheist, you find that the idea of the multiverse serves as a cornerstone of their belief system. Nevertheless, the multiverse is complete fiction—a product of their own imagination: wholly unscientific and, in fact, proves, rather than disproves, the existence of God. Why?
The anthropic principle states that the universe is finely tuned for biological life by fundamental, natural, mathematical constants. In other words, the physics of our universe has the precise calculations necessary for life to exist. If these constants were off even by minutely small increments, life would not be possible and we would not be here. So how do we explain the fact that our universe is precisely tuned for life? The Christian answers, “an intelligent designer,” while the atheist responds, “the multiverse.” The idea is that if there were an infinite number of expanding universes, there would exist in at least one, if not more, of these universes, the precise universal, mathematical constants necessary for life. Physicist Steven Weinberg, in conversation with Richard Dawkins, argued, “If you discovered a really impressive fine-tuning. . . I think you’d be left with only two explanations: a benevolent designer or a multiverse.”[1] As cosmologist Bernard Carr from Queen Mary University of London put it, “If you don’t want God, you’d better have a multiverse.”[2] Score one for the atheists! Not so fast.
Science hinges on the scientific method and the ability to make empirically testable predictions. The multiverse is a desperate attempt to escape the clear implications of an intelligent designer, back of our “privileged planet.” In recent years, several secular critics have come out opposing the multiverse idea as being untestable, and thus unscientific. Cosmologist and mathematician, George Ellis, writing in Scientific American stated, “The key step in justifying a multiverse is extrapolation from the known to the unknown, from testable to untestable,” and “none of the claims made my multiverse enthusiasts can be directly substantiated.”[3] Physicist Mark Buchanan stated, “These other domains—or ‘universes’—could well exist, although we currently have no observational evidence for them. . . there does seem to be something a little questionable with this vast multiplication of multiverses. . . In a sense, multiverse enthusiasts take a ‘leap of faith’ every bit as big as the leap to believing in a creator. . .”[4]
Remarkably, the very ones who regularly tout the “science,” and besmirch believers as rejecting science in favor of a fairy tale Creator, and argue that intelligent design can’t be mentioned in the classroom because it is “unscientific,” are now in the fiction-writing business themselves, fully dispensing with the scientific method in order to prop up their anti-God hypothesis. Astrophysicists Adam Riess and Mario Livio admitted, “Even just mentioning the multiverse idea. . . raises the blood pressure of some physicists. The notion seems hard to swallow and harder to test—perhaps signifying the end of the classical scientific method as we know it.”[5] The end of the scientific method? Ellis adds to this dilemma, stating, “Proponents of the multiverse. . . are implicitly redefining what is meant by”science”. . . The various “proofs,” in effect, propose that we should accept a theoretical explanation instead of insisting on observational testing. Such testing has, until now, been the central requirement of the scientific endeavor, and we abandon it at our peril. If we weaken the requirement of solid data, we weaken the core reason for the success of science over the past centuries.”[3] Theoretical physicist Lee Smolin, writing in an article entitled, “You Think There’s A Multiverse? Get Real,” adds to the chorus, postulating, “the multiverse fails as a scientific hypothesis. . . And thus with an infinite ensemble of unobservable entities we leave the domain of science behind.”[6]
While it’s clear that the multiverse idea is unscientific, some attempt to redefine science out of the classically understood method of empirical observation to the purely untestable and theoretical—read, science fiction. Ellis, again, explains, “A remarkable fact about our universe is that physical constants have just the right values needed to allow for complex structures, including living things. . . I agree that the multiverse is a possible valid explanation. . . arguably, it is the only scientifically based option we have right now. But we have no hope of testing it observationally.”[3] In the same breath, Ellis says that the multiverse is a “scientifically based” option and that it is not observationally testable. In effect, he is saying the multiverse is science that does not follow the scientific method, thus a scientific newspeak.
Over and over, the secularists readily admit that the multiverse must be accepted because the only alternative, an intelligent designer, is out of the question. Why? Why should God be banished with a wave of the hand? Because it goes against their worldview—their belief system, in which they only have faith in the natural, the material world, which excludes anything supernatural. Nevertheless, that puts belief in God and the multiverse in the same category: a belief system—religion. Cosmologist Paul Davies admitted, “Clearly, then, both religion and science are founded on faith—namely, on belief in the existence of something outside the universe, like an unexplained God or an unexplained set of physical laws, maybe even a huge ensemble of unseen universes, too.”[7] Thus, in a strange turn of events, the multiverse concept becomes the creationist’s best friend.
So why do secularists reject God to opt for a fairy tale alternative? The apostle Paul explains this in Romans 1:21, “because, although they knew God, they did not glorify Him as God, nor were thankful, but became futile in their thoughts, and their foolish hearts were darkened.” Atheists know the only alternative is God, but because of their anti-God prejudices, their thoughts become futile, wasteful, empty, and they resort to science fiction over their own principle of Occam’s Razor, which argues that the simplest, most obvious answer is the best explanation. This explanation is clearly spelled out in the previous verse of Romans 1, which some call the “intelligent design verse” of the Bible, “For since the creation of the world His invisible attributes are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even His eternal power and Godhead, so that they are without excuse.”
Let’s let the skeptics make the concluding argument for us, “Here’s the dilemma: if the universe began with a quantum particle blipping into existence, inflating godlessly into space-time and a whole zoo of materials, then why is it so well suited for life? For medieval philosophers, the purported perfection of the universe was the key to proving the existence of God. The universe is so fit for intelligent life that it must be the product of a powerful, benevolent external deity. Or, as popular theology might put it today: all this can’t be an accident.”[8] Does this not echo the Psalmist? “The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament shows His handiwork. Day unto day utters speech, and night unto night reveals knowledge. There is no speech nor language where their voice is not heard. Their line has gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world” (Ps. 19:1-4).
Gefter, Amanda. “Why It’s Not as Simple as God versus the Multiverse.” New Scientist. 2685:48, Dec. 6, 2008. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20026852-500-why-its-not-as-simple-as-god-vs-the-multiverse.
As quoted in Tim Folger. “Science’s Alternative to an Intelligent Creator: The Multiverse Theory.” DiscoverMagazine.com, Nov. 10, 2008. https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/sciences-alternative-to-an-intelligent-creator-the-multiverse-theory.
Ellis, George F.R. “Does the Multiverse Really Exist?” Scientific American. 305[2]:39-43, 2011. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/does-the-multiverse-really-exist.
Buchanan, Mark. “When Does Multiverse Speculation Cross into Fantasy?” New Scientist. 221[2952]:46-47, Jan. 18, 2014. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg22129520-900-when-does-multiverse-speculation-cross-into-fantasy.
Riess, Adam G., and Mario Livio. “The Puzzle of Dark Energy.” Scientific American. 314[3]:38-43, 2016. Republished at https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/dark-energy-no-answers-but-more-questions.
Smolin, Lee. “You Think There’s a Multiverse? Get Real.” New Scientist. 225[3004]:24-25, Jan. 17, 2015. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg22530040-200-you-think-theres-a-multiverse-get-real.
Davies, Paul. “Taking Science on Faith.” The New York Times, Nov. 24, 2007. https://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/24/opinion/24davies.html.
Rubenstein, Mary-Jane. “God versus the Multiverse: the 2500 Year War.” New Scientist, 228[3052/3053]:64,Dec. 19/26, 2015. https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg22830520-800-god-vs-the-multiverse-the-2500-year-war.