By Jeff Wilson
Synopsis: God created us with emotions, feelings and effections—which impact our relationship with Him and others. Yet, spiritual fellowship with our Lord and our brethren is founded upon the objective standard of revealed truth.
One of the most significant things that determines the course and outcome of our lives is how we discern and decide. On what basis do we make our decisions? What are the deep, often unspoken, and even unawares assumptions and values that underwrite why we choose to do what we do? In what authority are those assumptions and values grounded? Where do they come from? Where do they lead us?
One hallmark of the decaying culture that we live in is the replacement of objective authority with subjective legitimation. That subjective legitimation is typically grounded in our emotions—how we feel about something. We certainly see the consequences of this in the increasing social and political chaos of recent years. Young people in today’s society are commonly told (in secular education and by contemporary culture) that there are no absolutes, no transcendent frame of reference, and therefore no way to meaningfully and authoritatively speak of right and wrong, let alone good and evil. We find ourselves more and more in an era aptly described by the ancient refrain from the book of Judges: “In those days there was no king in Israel. Everyone did what was right in his own eyes” (Judg. 17:6; 21:25). Our culture calls us to be “true to ourselves,” “follow our hearts,” etc.
That refrain well captures an inescapable reality: if we do not submit to some form of authority exterior to ourselves (like a king), then we will invariably each follow the implicit authority of ourselves and our own desires and feelings (“. . .right in his own eyes”). One of the most obvious consequences of this move of authority into the supposed autonomous self is that it is becoming progressively harder to reason with people because they view their desires (what they want) and how they feel as sufficient grounds to justify whatever it is they are doing. Appealing to objective standards such as Scripture holds little weight, and even when people might acknowledge Scripture, they may well ignore its plain teaching by declaring that they are following “what it means to them” as though meaning itself is ultimately subjective. Everyone has “his own truth.”
It is anathema these days to suggest that people should tame and change their emotions: such would be challenging and denying their “authentic selves.” Yet Scripture certainly teaches that we must do exactly that: control and discipline our emotions. As a quick example, God asks the sulking prophet Jonah if he is right to be angry (Jonah 4:4, 9). Clearly, the Lord believed that Jonah could discipline and develop his emotions—learning to be angry at the right time at the right things in the right way.
One way of describing the emotionally oriented, subjective, self-oriented authority in our culture—particularly as it pertains to religion—is through a concept called Moral Therapeutic Deism (MTD). The term was coined in a 2005 book called Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of Teenagers by sociologists Christian Smith and Melinda Denton. In the book, they summarized the findings of their large-scale surveying of the nature of religious belief in the then-rising generation as reducible to these five basic ideas: “A God exists who created and order the world and watches over human life on earth;” “God wants people to be good, nice, and fair to each other, as taught in the Bible and by most world religions;” “The central goal of life is to be happy and to feel good about oneself;” “God does not need to be particularly involved in one’s life except when He is needed to resolve a problem;” “Good people go to heaven when they die.” Thus, the title the authors ascribed to such a belief system: moral, because it has some vaguely defined goal of being “good;” therapeutic, because it partakes of our culture’s obsession with psychological well-being and self-esteem, i.e., “happiness;” and deism, because it believes in a “God,” even though he is not the God who objectively defines Himself and His nature through Scripture.
This is as apt a short description as I know of for grasping the spirit of the age when it comes to religion. Its authority is found primarily in one’s self—there is no emphasis on an external authority like the biblical text for defining what is “good” or how we will be judged when eternal destinies are meted out. Perhaps, most crucially, the goal of life is not to live a Christ-shaped, others-focused, sacrificially-losing-self-in-the-loving-obedience-of-God type life. The goal is to be happy and feel good about one’s self—all self-oriented concepts with emotional uplift and pleasure are the measuring stick of religious accomplishment.
There are two areas I particularly want to highlight in discussing the danger of dwelling on our emotions. The first is in the area of religious “experience.” Many religious groups emphasize the emotional over the doctrinal—attracting attendees and members not with the unvarnished gospel but with emotional experiences through music, lights, hype-type sermons. The service becomes a de facto performance. Then, often enough, the Holy Spirit is brought into the mix as well, with people being taught to believe and expect that the Spirit will give some sort of personal religious experience or feeling. In short, religion is reduced to how it makes you feel rather than calling you to repent of your sin and conform your will to God’s.
The other aspect of the focus on emotions and emotionalism that I see is the growing use of, and influence of, various forms of counseling among brethren. This matter is much more subtle and requires nuance. I want to tread lightly and carefully here. I recognize that there are various mental health issues that are painful to live with and require legitimate forms of intervention—medical and otherwise. Schizophrenia, bi-polar, clinical depression, autism, developmental disorders, and so forth are real and people can benefit from various treatments.
However, with that crucial caveat stated, there is still, in my experience, a growing reliance by many on various forms of counseling for various matters. I am speaking of a general trend I have noticed among us, not passing judgment on every person’s individual situation. The danger here is that much counseling/therapy—even by so-called “Christian” counselors—is ultimately based on various assumptions about human nature and what constitutes mental health, as well as various psychological theories that are reductionistic and do not take into full account what it means that humans bear the image of God. In short, counseling can often define people’s well-being in primarily emotional terms rather than the scriptural worldview that calls us to deny ourselves, endure hardship for the gospel, and suffer for righteousness’ sake—even unto death, if necessary.
I knowingly risk outrage by some for even stating this, but to my mind, it is evidence of how dependent some have become on the therapeutic framework for their own emotional stability. While I do not have all the answers, or the space presently to balance legitimate mental health care with worldly philosophies masquerading as paths to psychological well-being, I believe that the psychological view of mental health is eclipsing the Bible’s worldview among more and more of us. As evidence, just consider how much of psychology’s and counseling’s vocabulary is coming to replace the Bible’s vocabulary—what used to be “sin” is now “addiction.” There is no “disease” called “alcoholism” in the Bible; rather, Scripture refers to the sin of drunkenness which God declares must be stopped. There are no “addictions” in the Bible; instead, there is just slavery to sin (Rom. 6:16–23). We are medicalizing away sin and we need to recognize how our subtly shifting vocabulary—often employed to soften the emotional blow of confronting sin—is itself an early form of accepting the world’s version of reality.
In our therapeutic culture, the supremacy of emotions means that upsetting someone emotionally is more and more considered on par with physical violence. So we soft-pedal the emotionally troubling truth about sin and the world. That words like “sin,” “judgment,” “hell,” and so forth are becoming more rarely spoken and taught among us is yet further evidence of the softening of the truth for what are emotional reasons. Such words are hard to hear, so we no longer speak them: just like Felix listening to Paul in the first century, unvarnished truth can make the stubborn heart uncomfortable—even fearful (cf. Acts 24:24–25).
In his short novella, The Ball and The Cross, written a century ago, G. K. Chesterton rightly saw the danger in the then-new-and-emerging science of psychology to redefine reality and mental health in ways that were themselves unreal—to allow man to define himself rather than to be defined by God through Scripture. Thus, in his story, Chesterton had the devil become incarnate as a psychologist. The power to “scientifically” decide and declare what is mentally healthy (taking that authority away from Scripture) is the power to define what is “good” for man.
Similarly, sociologist Philip Rieff, writing in The Triumph of the Therapeutic in the mid-twentieth century, noted the growing influence of psychology on how we define ourselves: “Religious man was born to be saved; psychological man is born to be pleased. The difference was established long ago, when ‘I believe,’ the cry of the ascetic, lost precedence to ‘one feels,’ the caveat of the therapeutic. If the therapeutic is to win out, then surely the psychotherapist will be his secular spiritual guide.” It is significant that by the 1960s, Rieff—who was himself an atheist—recognized the tension between the therapeutic and the truly religious worldview.
A specific example of the incursion of the authority of counseling into the church involves the matter of marriage. Marriage is a spiritual and biblical matter long before it is a legal, sociological, or psychological matter. Scripture defines roles that are to be fulfilled in marriage and yet culture has emphasized subjective emotional fulfillment over objective duty to one’s spouse. Just watch any so-called romantic comedy to see how outsized the emphasis on emotional and romantic fulfillment trumps the drudgery of sacrificing oneself—and one’s happiness—for one’s spouse. Yet, I wonder at how many preachers and elders are becoming more comfortable outsourcing marital counseling to “experts” outside the congregation. How many Christians are spending more time reading secular books on marriage by “experts” than they are studying Scripture and repenting of their own sins in their marriages? No one denies that there are bad marriages where one spouse refuses to repent and that can cause great suffering; however, that reality does not change Scripture’s teachings regarding the permanent nature of marriage or one’s duty to fulfill one’s marital role regardless of the other person’s substantial sin. Ultimately, the therapeutic mindset must bow to the fact that the Bible calls us to suffer for righteousness’ sake if necessary (Matt. 5:10; 1 Pet. 3:14; 2 Tim. 4:5). Jesus achieved our salvation only by practicing this reality Himself (Heb. 12:3). We can either grow strong in faith as we take part in Christ’s sufferings in this life (2 Cor. 1:5; 2 Cor. 4:10-11; Col. 1:24; 1 Pet. 4:13), or we can choose a “therapeutic victim mentality,” which is much easier and more satisfying emotionally. Early Christians suffered much, but they did not “process their trauma,” but actually were told to find joy in their trials because of the spiritual good that enduring hardship and suffering can do for us if we are thinking scripturally and not worldly (Jas. 1:2-4).
I am not saying there is never a place for counseling. Still, I perceive a growing struggle for authority among God’s people between the therapeutic perspective and the biblical perspective. I literally once observed a woman declare more confidence in her counselor than in her elders. Counseling often brings with it a “therapeutic” mindset that quickly creates a worldview and an emotional state that is contrary to Scripture. Perhaps more needs to be said to develop this point at another time.
In reality, there is nothing truly new about any of this. Both the Old Testament (particularly the prophets) and the New Testament (particularly Paul) attest to this.
In Isaiah 30:9-11, God described His people thusly:
For they are a rebellious people, lying children, children unwilling to hear the instruction of the Lord; who say to the seers, “Do not see,” and to the prophets, “Do not prophesy to us what is right; speak to us smooth things, prophesy illusions, leave the way, turn aside from the path, let us hear no more about the Holy One of Israel.”
Similarly, and more familiarly, Paul told Timothy near the end of his final letter that “the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions, and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths” (2 Tim. 4:3-4). If it was possible in the first century to “accumulate. . . teachers to suit their own passions,” how much more is that a danger today with the internet and all manner of false—but emotionally pleasing—teaching readily accessible?
As much as we rightly fault preachers who use emotionalism in a worldly way to attract hearers and water down the word of God, we also need to challenge hearers on this count. Worldly preachers manipulate emotions because there is an audience for such preaching and teaching. In reality, we like emotionally appealing words. We want to be promised comfort, not called to repentance. We want to feel good about ourselves, not have the light of God’s holiness shined on our sinful impurities that yet need to be purged.
An important point to be raised here. False teachers who use emotions to manipulate their hearers certainly lead people astray. Yet, in Scripture, the problem is the audience for false teaching as much as the false teacher himself. There is a sense in which I am less worried about the individual preacher who seeks to excite his audience with preaching about religious prayer experiences that make his hands tingle, than I am about the appetite for such teaching among brethren in the first place. I am less concerned about an individual preacher than I am about the troubling lack of scriptural groundedness and spiritual discernment among preachers and elders more broadly in continuing to use and support such a man. The existence of such preaching among us (and the willingness of brethren to accept it) is as much a symptom of large-scale spiritual decay as it is the sole and singular cause of apostasy. The Lord has a history of giving people what they want—as a form of judgment—just as Israel declared its desire for a king like all the nations and was given the disastrous Saul (cf, 1 Kings 22:18-22; Isa. 6:9-10; Ezek. 14:7-11; 2 Thess. 2:9-12). I worry that perhaps the rise of such teachers among us might lead to the same outcome.
We are already becoming corrupted by the spirit of the age in that too many want emotional peace and comfort and shallow “encouragement” rather than truth that wounds our egos and pricks our emotions even as it purifies us for the presence of the only One who is Holy. “Blessed are those who mourn,” said the One who is Himself the only Way, Truth, and Life. Too many want the “peace” of proof-texted life-hacks, self-care, self-esteem, self-fulfillment.
The Christian life is not about avoiding suffering but overcoming it through faithful endurance. As the apostle Peter taught, the one who has suffered has ceased from sin (1 Pet. 4:1). As the Hebrew writer admonished: “For you have need of endurance, so that when you have done the will of God, you may receive what is promised” (Heb. 10:36).
Chesterton, G. K. The Ball and The Cross. New York: John Lane Co., 1909.
Rieff, Philip. The Triumph of the Therapeutic: Uses of Faith after Freud. University Of Chicago Press, 1987.
Smith, Christian, and Melinda Lundquist Denton. Soul Searching: The Religious and Spiritual Lives of American Teenagers Reprint Edition. Oxford University Press, 2009.