QnA Graphic

QUESTIONS and ANSWERS

By Bobby Graham

Question

Was it just the apostles or the 120 disciples who were baptized in the Holy Spirit in Acts 2?

Answer

Though it is correct that the 120 were gathered with the apostles in chapter 1, it cannot be established that they were present on Pentecost some days later when the Holy Spirit descended in fulfillment of the Lord’s promise (Acts 1:5; 2:1-4; John 14-16). Neither were they mentioned in Acts 2, nor is there any reason to conclude they were then present with the twelve apostles. On the other hand, there is much evidence to conclude that it was the twelve who were being immersed in the Holy Spirit.

The original promise of Holy Sprit baptism given by John concerning the work of Jesus Christ, in contrast to John’s own work, certainly was later narrowed by Jesus Himself when speaking to the twelve about the work which they would begin on Pentecost (Acts 1:5).

The gathering of the apostles and the 120 in Acts 1:15ff was preparatory to the events of Pentecost. The first chapter closes by referring to the apostles in verse 26, now supplemented by the Lord’s choice of Matthias, evidently focusing upon the very ones with whom Luke would start his presentation of Pentecost events in chapter two.

Because pronouns have antecedents (nouns or pronouns referred to), we look for the antecedent of “they”in Acts 2:1. The rule is to find the closest noun or pronoun to which “they” could refer. It is the noun “apostles” in Acts 1:26. Nowhere do the 120 appear after the sole mention in 1:15. Because of the time lapse between the events in chapter one and chapter two, it becomes imperative to omit the 120 as a possible identification of “they” in chapter two.

Chapter two furnishes multiple references to the apostles: they were all together in one place (v. 1); the sound of a rushing strong wind filled the house where they were sitting (v. 2); tongues appeared and rested upon each of them (v. 3); now filled with the Spirit, they spoke in other languages, as the Spirit caused them to speak (v. 4); the ones thus speaking were Galileans, as the apostles were (v. 7; cf. 1:11); Peter and the eleven other apostles spoke in explanation and defense of the events of the day (v. 14); the “they” of Luke’s account now become “we” in Peter’s affirmation, because he associates himself with the other apostles as witnesses of the resurrected Jesus (v. 32).

To deduce that more than the apostles were included in the fulfillment of the Lord’s promise of baptism in the Holy Spirit is to strain the passages where the promise and those where its fulfillment appear. This is how many false ideas/doctrines begin: by reading into passages what is not necessarily implied therein.

There is an adequate basis for teaching that the apostles received Holy Spirit baptism in Acts 2, but there is no foundation for affirming that others did!


Author Image
Article Image
Ad Image